Europe’s electricity networks are ageing just as electrification, renewable generation, EVs and data centres place greater demands on them. Around 40 per cent of Europe’s distribution grids are already more than 40 years old, according to the European Commission. This does not mean that every transformer within those networks is the same age or in the same condition, but it illustrates the scale of the lifecycle-management challenge facing asset owners.
As the industry looks ahead to CWIEME Berlin 2027, Fernando Monteiro de Melo, a transformer lifecycle and service expert at Siemens Energy, explains why decisions about whether to continue operating, refurbish, modernise or replace a transformer should be based on condition, risk and future system requirements rather than age alone.
A 40-year-old transformer sounds old. In practice, however, age alone tells us relatively little about whether it is approaching the end of its useful life. Age is an important screening factor, but it must be interpreted together with condition, operating history and future system requirements.
Two transformers manufactured in the same year can reach very different conditions depending on how they have been operated. Loading, ambient conditions, design margins, operating events, through-faults, moisture ingress and maintenance history can all influence degradation.
Equally, a transformer that is only 20 years old could already require major intervention or, in some cases, replacement if it has spent much of its life overloaded or operating in challenging conditions.
Rather than using an arbitrary age threshold, asset owners need a condition-, risk- and criticality-based approach. That means building a picture of the transformer using multiple sources of information.
Dissolved gas analysis can provide indications of what is happening inside the transformer, while physical and chemical analysis of the oil can reveal moisture levels and other signs of deterioration.
The condition of the solid insulation can be estimated using oil-based ageing indicators and operational history. Where representative paper samples are safely available, degree of polymerisation testing can provide more direct information about cellulose degradation. Temperature, loading, leaks, environmental conditions and maintenance history add further pieces to the puzzle.
The important thing is to bring all these pieces of information together. No single measurement provides the complete answer. The quality of the decision depends on combining diagnostic results, trends over time, design knowledge and engineering judgement.
Future requirements matter too. A transformer could remain in good physical condition but no longer have the capacity required by a site or network. In that case, replacement or a technically viable uprating may be the appropriate decision.
The decision therefore has several dimensions: technical condition, operational criticality, future loading, safety and environmental risk, outage availability, access to spare parts, intervention lead time and total lifecycle cost. The technically possible option is not always the option that creates the greatest value for the asset owner.
The same principle is changing transformer maintenance. Historically, maintenance was often dictated by the calendar: particular interventions might take place after two years, five years or another fixed interval. Better offline diagnostics, online monitoring and data analytics now allow operators to move towards maintenance strategies informed more closely by actual asset condition and risk.
That does not mean monitoring makes transformers maintenance-free. Components within the same transformer age differently. Bushings and tap changers, for example, can be important contributors to critical failures, while conservators, breathers and other components require their own interventions. Monitoring can help operators detect certain developing problems earlier, while periodic inspections and offline diagnostics remain necessary for failure modes that cannot be reliably identified by online measurements alone.
The real value of monitoring is its ability to provide earlier visibility of certain developing conditions. When combined with diagnostics and engineering interpretation, it can move transformer management from reacting to faults towards anticipating and mitigating risk.
That distinction is becoming increasingly important because Europe cannot simply replace every ageing transformer.
Life extension and replacement should therefore not be presented as competing ideologies. They are complementary tools within a long-term fleet strategy. The objective is to intervene at the right time, with the right scope, on the right assets.
Electricity demand is rising while much of the installed transformer fleet is ageing. At the same time, demand for new transformers and critical components is increasing, making replacement lead time, execution capacity and outage planning important parts of the asset decision. New transformers will remain essential as networks expand, but they are only one part of the near-term response.
That makes the existing fleet a valuable resource. Consider an operator assessing a fleet of ageing transformers. Condition and risk data may show that a small number have reached the end of their technically or economically justifiable life and should be replaced.
Other transformers of a similar age may remain suitable for targeted maintenance, refurbishment or modernisation. Depending on their condition, this could involve oil treatment and drying, replacement of bushings or tap changers, cooling upgrades, improved monitoring or more substantial on-site or factory refurbishment, which in selected cases may include winding replacement or redesign.
The aim is not to keep ageing assets running indefinitely. It is to avoid replacing serviceable infrastructure simply because it has passed a particular age.
Where the intervention is performed is another strategic decision. On-site solutions can reduce transport challenges and outage duration for selected scopes, while factory-based refurbishment offers a more controlled environment for deep interventions, drying, redesign and testing. The appropriate model depends on asset condition, transport feasibility, required test scope, available outage window and intervention complexity.
Nor is the aim to wait until deterioration removes the available options. The greatest value is usually created when assessment and intervention begin early enough to allow engineering, component procurement, outage planning and replacement contingency to be managed proactively.
It is also important to distinguish between different types of intervention. A repair addresses a specific defect or failure. Refurbishment restores condition and functionality, while retrofit or modernisation introduces an improvement compared with the original design, for example through upgraded cooling, monitoring, protection or components. Replacement becomes appropriate when the remaining technical risk, required capacity or lifecycle economics no longer justify further intervention.
This question is becoming important enough to warrant a dedicated space at CWIEME Berlin 2027. The show’s new Transformer Lifecycle Hub will focus specifically on what happens after installation, bringing together expertise in condition assessment and diagnostics, digital monitoring, maintenance, refurbishment, oil treatment, component replacement, remanufacturing and responsible end-of-life solutions.
For asset owners, these decisions are all connected. Understanding whether an existing transformer can safely remain in service can help determine where maintenance budgets are spent, where refurbishment is justified and where scarce new equipment is most urgently required.
The commercial comparison should therefore extend beyond the initial price of the intervention. Asset owners need to consider avoided downtime, failure consequences, expected remaining life, operating efficiency, outage and transport costs, spare-part availability, execution risk and the timing of future replacement. In some cases, predictability and speed may create more value than the lowest upfront cost.
Perhaps the biggest advantage of condition assessment comes when operators stop looking at transformers individually and begin considering the fleet as a whole.
A health index can provide a consolidated view of physical condition. When combined with asset criticality and the consequences of failure, it can support a broader risk-based prioritisation of the fleet. An asset in relatively good condition might nevertheless warrant earlier replacement because its role is exceptionally critical. Another in poorer condition may receive a different intervention priority if system redundancy exists, provided that continued operation remains technically justified and subject to appropriate risk controls.
That visibility gives operators time. Instead of waiting for a failure and urgently sourcing a replacement, they can identify which assets require intervention earlier, plan maintenance and refurbishment, and prioritise new equipment where it is genuinely needed.
This fleet-level visibility also allows asset owners to create a coordinated pipeline of maintenance, component replacement, refurbishment and new-equipment procurement, rather than treating each transformer as an isolated emergency.
When a transformer finally reaches the end of its usable life, responsible decommissioning can allow materials such as copper and steel to be recovered through established recycling routes. Depending on their condition, design and applicable requirements, selected components may also be evaluated for controlled reuse or emergency-spares strategies.
However, circularity should never override safety, traceability or technical qualification. Extending life is sustainable only when it is also safe, reliable and economically justified.
Europe undoubtedly needs new transformers. But with electricity demand increasing, grids expanding and manufacturing capacity under pressure, new equipment is only one part of the answer.
For a transformer that has spent four decades on the grid, therefore, the most useful question is not “How old is it?” It is “What condition is it in, how critical is it to the network, what will the system need from it in the future, and what is the safest and most economically justified next step?”
That is the information operators need to decide whether the 40-year-old machine should retire, continue under enhanced monitoring, receive a targeted intervention, undergo refurbishment or modernisation, or be replaced through a planned transition.
CWIEME Berlin 2027 takes place from April 27 to 29, 2027 at Messe Berlin. Discover the new Transformer Lifecycle Hub and other features coming to the show on the event website.